Let me paint you a picture. It’s a lovely Bengaluru evening. My friends and I are at the Kanteerava Stadium watching an electric match between Bengaluru FC and Mumbai City FC, and watching Chhetri play truly felt like a dream. But in the back of our minds, my friend and I knew we had to be prepared for 8 pm.

You see, it was a Tuesday night, which also meant that Guerilla Diner would open its reservations for the week at that time, and we had to be ready. And we were. Thumbs were exercised to ensure speedy typing, connectivity had been checked, and we were sitting at the edge of our seats, waiting to conquer this.

But like all good things, our dreams came to an end. Bengaluru didn’t win that night, and neither did we. By 8:02 pm, all the slots were booked except for an obscure Tuesday 5 pm reservation, when we all had class and couldn’t go. I look back at our disappointed faces from that day and think about how we treated getting this reservation like an Olympic sport — a high-stakes competition.

And that is what dining in metropolitan Indian cities has begun to feel like. Securing a reservation at some of the country’s most sought-after restaurants increasingly resembles standing in line to buy Coldplay tickets or limited-edition sneaker drops. At the centre of this shift is a growing appetite for exclusivity. Intimate chef’s tables, tasting-menu formats, and restaurants with deliberately limited seating have created an ecosystem where scarcity is not just inevitable, but desirable. The harder a reservation is to secure, the more coveted the experience becomes.

To dissect how this competitive sport-like Herculean task of grabbing a reservation has affected both the customer experience and the spaces themselves, we spoke to diners across the country and Chef Hussain Shehzad, the Executive Chef at Hunger Inc. Hospitalities (Papa's) about this trend we’re seeing in the hospitality industry.

This creation of a sense of manufactured scarcity, where a table at one of these restaurants becomes something to covet, is evident in the way many diners describe their experiences. For Bengaluru-based diner Harnoor Bali, the issue points to something beyond the difficulty of securing a reservation. “For me it's just irritating that half the times these restaurants aren't even fully booked but they still turn you away. One restaurant in Bengaluru said no walk-ins, we're fully booked but we'll take your number in case something comes up and then they called us in ten minutes. And when we went there the restaurant was empty. I also hate how they get so competitive and make bookings a common thing, I miss when you could just walk in at 7 and get a table anywhere."

Bali's frustration points to a broader shift in how dining is being experienced in urban India. Traditionally, restaurants were spontaneous spaces. The rise of reservation-first dining has introduced a layer of planning and gatekeeping that can make the experience feel less hospitable and more transactional. Whether or not the scarcity is intentional, the perception of exclusivity becomes part of the restaurant's identity. In some cases, a fully booked reservation system can signal desirability and prestige more effectively than an occupied dining room ever could. For diners, however, that same signal can create the feeling that access is being strategically controlled.

Pune-based diner Manav K points out why places like these remain appealing. “To be entirely honest, going out has become a whole ordeal for my family since COVID. Between traffic, finding parking, and managing everyone's schedules, especially now that the kids are working too, it takes a lot more effort to plan an outing. So when we do decide to go out, we want to make sure it's a place that counts. That's why we tend to gravitate towards places like these, which curate an experience that feels worth both the money and the time we invest in it.” 

Manav's perspective highlights the other side of the equation. If diners are willing to treat reservations as coveted prizes, it is often because the economics of going out have changed. In this context, restaurants that promise a carefully curated experience offer something beyond just food, providing reassurance that the effort involved in getting there will be worthwhile. This helps explain why scarcity can become an attractive proposition rather than merely an inconvenience. The difficulty of securing a reservation functions as a signal that the experience on the other side is worth pursuing. A hard-to-get table suggests consistency and a level of demand that validates the investment of time and money.

'Reservation Gym', is an interactive website created by a Bengaluru based Yuck Collective, a group of three Indian stand-up comedians. The website allows users to practise booking restaurant reservations against the clock. Complete with forms, personal details and simulated booking pressure, the website transforms securing a table into a skill that can be trained like a competitive sport.

The idea emerged from lived frustration. "We all had problems booking and reserving these places," the collective explains. "And we realised what would actually be helpful is if I could practise for this because in the moment you fuck up and have to start from scratch, it's such a pain." While the project is clearly satirical, its humour works because it exaggerates a reality many diners already recognise. 

Yuck Collective sees the absurdity of the situation as what made the concept resonate so widely. "It's become so intense for good food. It's so silly. And that's one of the reasons why it resonated," they say. The website pokes fun at the increasingly gamified nature of dining culture, where timing and technical proficiency can sometimes feel as important as taste.

The collective argues that reservation systems, which may have originated as practical tools for managing demand, have in some cases evolved into mechanisms that amplify a sense of exclusivity. "The frustration came from something that started off from a good place and now it's become this arbitrary mechanism that people have put over these places just to make it feel more valued," they explain.

For Chef Hussain Shehzad, Executive Chef at Hunger Inc. Hospitality, the rise of intimate dining spaces reflects a broader shift in what diners expect from restaurants. "Diners are no longer just looking for good food; they are looking for experiences that feel personal, emotional, and memorable," he explains. In smaller formats, the relationship between the guest and the restaurant changes entirely. 

That intimacy, however, comes with limitations. Speaking about Papa's, which accommodates only 12 guests per service and operates four nights a week, Shehzad notes that the limited availability is "simply a reflection of the format, the space we are in, and the kind of experience we are trying to create." The very qualities that make these restaurants desirable, the personalisation, storytelling, and attention to detail, are difficult to replicate at scale.

While scarcity may generate anticipation, he believes it cannot become the point of the experience itself. "Intimacy should never become exclusivity for the sake of exclusivity," he says. "People may come initially because of curiosity or anticipation, but they return because they feel emotionally connected to the space."

Taken together, these perspectives reveal a contradiction at the heart of contemporary dining culture. Diners complain about impossible reservations while setting reminders to secure them. Restaurants insist that limited access is a consequence of intimacy rather than a strategy, while audiences continue to interpret scarcity as a marker of value. What's undeniable is that somewhere between all of these perfectly reasonable positions, the reservation itself has become an inextricable part of the modern dining experience, particularly if you want a certain standard of quality.

Back at Kanteerava Stadium, my friends and I left without the victory we were hoping for. But looking back, what strikes me most is how natural it felt to treat a restaurant reservation as a competitive event. And this made me realise that even though, the meal may still be the destination, for a growing number of diners, the journey now begins the moment reservations open.

If you enjoyed reading this, here's more from Homegrown:

Nila, Bengaluru’s 'Backwaters' Menu Turns Kerala’s Ecology Into A 12-Course Story

No Fuss, All Flavour: Papa's Gives Mumbai An Unpretentious 12-Course Dining Experience

'Tony': Revisiting The Mercurial Chef's Unique Relationship With The Subcontinent