This article argues that Diya Vij’s appointment to lead New York City’s Department of Cultural Affairs is significant not only for representation, but for what it reveals about how seriously some global cities treat culture within governance. New York institutionalises cultural policy through structured funding, public art oversight, and neighbourhood support, recognising culture as central to economic vitality and social cohesion. In contrast, Indian cities like Mumbai and Bengaluru lack empowered municipal cultural departments, with cultural policy largely centralised under the Ministry of Culture and focused on heritage preservation rather than contemporary urban ecosystems.
When someone like Diya Vij takes charge of the New York City Department of Cultural Affairs, the conversation should not stop at representation. Yes, it matters that a South Asian voice is shaping cultural policy in one of the world’s most influential cities. But the deeper significance lies in what the role itself represents: a city that treats culture as a serious, structured arm of governance.
New York’s Department of Cultural Affairs distributes hundreds of millions in funding, this money oversees public art, supports neighbourhood institutions, embeds culture into urban policy and ensures that money is being pumped into the right channels to bolster the city's thriving cultural economy.The position exists because the city recognises that cultural life is central to economic vitality, tourism, education, and social cohesion. It is not just peripheral, something fun, or just an interesting add on to a city's landscape, instead, it is the landscape.
In India, the gap is less about who holds office and more about the fact that comparable local offices barely exist.
Cultural policy here is largely centralised under the Ministry of Culture, which does vital work in preserving monuments, archives, and classical art forms. But at the municipal level, in cities like Mumbai, which are cities that were built ground up around and for the culture it was fostering, there is rarely a dedicated, empowered cultural department with long-term urban vision. There is no coherent strategy behind how we can mobilise and channel culture, it often falls between tourism boards, event permissions, or ad hoc festival committees.
Cultural funding should be debated with the same seriousness as transport or housing. Cities must recognises culture as both identity and industry.
Indian cities are no less culturally vibrant. Mumbai’s film and theatre ecosystems influence national imagination. Bengaluru’s design and music scenes shape youth culture across the country. But the lack of institutional focus means these ecosystems survive through resilience rather than policy support. The burden falls on artists and private patrons instead of structured municipal planning.
This is why appointments like Vij’s matter in a global context. They highlight what becomes possible when cities create formal, accountable cultural leadership. The issue in India is not simply about representation of people of colour, a category that looks different in our context anyway, but about representation of culture itself within governance. Without dedicated municipal cultural offices, there is no sustained strategy for affordability, access, preservation of contemporary practices, or equitable funding.
As Indian cities expand rapidly, the question is not whether they have culture, they overflow with it. The question is whether they are willing to institutionalise it. Leadership roles with real authority over cultural ecosystems signal seriousness. Until Indian municipalities create similarly empowered positions, culture will remain celebrated rhetorically but marginal in policy.
Urban futures are shaped not only by flyovers and tech parks, but by championing for the city's underground movements and artists feel supported and taken care of. The challenge for India is structural: to build city-level cultural governance that treats creativity as infrastructure.
A City In Conversation: Homegrown Guide To The 6th Kochi Muziris Biennale
Rediscover The Soul Of Indian Cities Through 6 One-Of-A-Kind Urban Heritage Walks
Goodbye, Mumbai: Young Indians Tell Us Why They're Leaving Metros For Smaller Cities